Tegel

Hi, Blocking a user with the assumption that he/she's running a bot by just evaluating his/her edit speed is I think a great mistake. It's very common in almost every wiki that user make more than a few edits/ article. For ex. check my contributions in species Wikipedia. [1]. I hope you remove the block for that user becuase his/her contributions are valuable. Regards.--Alperen (mesaj) 17:23, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

These edits are done with bot software. 30 edits during one minute from 5 different IP-addresses is not from a human editor. Feel free to provide me with a link to a local policy that says that it's OK to run a bot without an account. -- Tegel (mesaj) 17:32, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

I can hardly see more than 10 edits per minute on this wiki and I think it's possible by human edit for such length. Do you mean that the same IP is editing on other language Wiktionary wikis? Also why didn't you try to communicate with the user?--Alperen (mesaj) 17:46, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

The user used 5 different IP-addresses at the same time. See contribution from IP-address 144.122.238.21 thru 144.122.238.26. It's difficult to communicate with someone that just changes IP-address. And posting a message on the talk page will not be visible for the bot software. All I'm asking is that the user create a separate bot-account and get a bot-flag. I have nothing against the edit itself and I'm sure that they are OK, but as you can see here at least one local user has issues with the contribution. -- Tegel (mesaj) 18:00, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

Yep, the user might be on a dynamic IP range and his IP may change over time, and his edit count may be about 5-10 edits per minute but I still don't think that this proves that (s)he is using a bot (software) while doing the edits. A bot can make a lot more changes per minute such as this one ([2]). I think you should have tried communication at least once. Thanks for the dialogue.--Alperen (mesaj) 18:21, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

Hi, I've created a new account and a bot account for that account. I also added a bot request. You might wanna check here [3]. I hope the bot request is correct. Best. Gamsızbaykuş (mesaj) 18:36, 10 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

That's good. But I would say that a bot flag is not enough. There will need to be a local discussion to get consensus about creating articles with a bot. -- Tegel (mesaj) 07:00, 11 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

• Many of that user's new articles had wrong definitions. I deleted all of them and I'll care about it, because I was in abroad when that user has started to create these articles. Thanks for your attention --Sαвяí¢αи76^ileti 00:09, 14 Eylül 2013 (UTC)

Tegel ile bir mesajlaşma başlatın.

Mesaj sayfaları, Vikisözlük adlı projedeki insanların içerik üzerine tartışabileceği en iyi yerlerden biridir. Tegel adlı kullanıcı ile iletişime geçmek için yeni bir tartışma başlatın. Buraya yazacağınız şeyler herkes tarafından görülecektir.

Bir tartışma başlat